Freo's View

MANNING DEVELOPMENT GETS JDAP APPROVAL

Posted in architecture, city of fremantle, development, heritage, Uncategorized by freoview on January 23, 2018

 

ma 4

 

The application for the $ 10 million development of the Fremantle Manning Buildings was unanimously approved by all five members of the WA Joint Development Assessment Panel-JDAP this morning with some minor amendments. The most significant one was to allow the percentage for the art contribution to go to reinstating the former balcony and verandah along William Street.

The Manning property runs from William to Market Street and all along the southern side of the High Street Mall, and is owned by Fremantle-based developers Silverleaf.

The development includes a micro brewery with tavern and restaurant, as well as commercial and retail accommodation.

The future of the Wrightson’s barber shop was a concern and consideration during the deliberations with questions asked why we do not have planning policies that protect social heritage as well as buildings.

We were assured that the Wrightson’s shop front will be retained and that the barbers have been offered relocation to Market Street, but Chair Ian Birch expressed the sentiment of all panel members that he hoped the developers/owners would be able to accommodate the barbers in the same location.

Councillor Jon Strachan was concerned about the staged development aspects of the proposal but was assured by the architect that it was simply not practical to do it all in one stage.

Strachan also said that the initial drawings had raised concern at council, but that the developers had positively worked with City of Fremantle planning and heritage staff to improve the application and respect the heritage of the building.

He said that the quality of the heritage report gave him confidence that an outcome the city can be proud off will be achieved.

Councillor Rachel Pemberton said it was nice to see heritage buildings getting a new lease of life. She also said we should keep in perspective that in the 1990s there were 21 licensed pubs in Fremantle and now only 11.

Chair Ian Birch said that the active use and refurbishment was the best way of protecting heritage buildings.

Two other amendments were part of the approval. One that heritage values override other development considerations and the other that an archeological dig will be conducted before the commencement of the development.

Roel Loopers

PERCENTAGE FOR HERITAGE IMPORTANT FOR FREMANTLE

Posted in architecture, art, city of fremantle, development, local government, Uncategorized by freoview on January 10, 2018

 

An interesting flaw in the City of Fremantle’s Percentage for the Arts or Heritage policy came to light during the Planning Committee on Wednesday evening.

Fremantle Society president John Dowson made the very sensible suggestion that the percentage should be used to reinstate the wrought-iron verandahs on the Manning Buildings when they are developed, but was told it is not possible to use the percentage for the arts/heritage on a private building.

I had just written down that the Quest Hotel and another Pakenham Street development both have percentage for the art works attached to their buildings, when Silverleaf director Gerard O’Brien made exactly the same point to the Councillors.

The percentage for the arts and heritage policy was introduced to enhance and beautify the public realm, and Councillor Rachel Pemberton made the realistic observation that verandahs are very much in the public realm.

It is absolutely non-sensical that building owners and developers cannot spend percentage for heritage and arts money on beautifying the public realm with heritage features, but are forced to spend it on often pretty mediocre and uninspiring art that can be attached to their buildings.

Developers tell me that a lot of the money from percentage for the arts is spend on administration and art consultants, and not on the actual art work, so let gets some reality in a policy that is clearly flawed and needs to be amended, so that we can encourage developers to reinstate verandahs, which look much better than modern awnings.

It would be a win win for all!

And to make it clear! I love great public art and believe the percentage for the arts and heritage is good, but it needs to be realistic and flexible.

There are many silly rules and regulations in our planning laws and some of them are detrimental to achieving the best outcome. All the community wants is the very best building outcomes, not silly bureaucratic nonsense.

Roel Loopers

MANNING BUILDINGS DEVELOPMENT BEFORE PLANNING COMMITTEE

Posted in architecture, city of fremantle, heritage, Uncategorized by freoview on January 6, 2018

 

The proposal for the development and part demolition of the Manning buildings will come before the City of Fremantle Planning Committee this Wednesday January 10 at 6pm.

The plans by developers Silverleaf include a 250 patron dining area and 250 patron tavern and a micro-brewery, as well as office and retail accommodation.

The approval authority for the $ 10 million project is the WA Joint Development Assessment Panel. The City of Fremantle Officer’s Recommendation to the CoF Planning Committee is to recommend the conditional approval of the three storey development, that will retain the Manning Arcade between the High Street mall and Paddy Troy Lane.

The modernisation of the Frematle CBD is inevitable and should in general be welcomed I believe, as long as new development proposals are considerate of the heritage character of the inner city.

Silverleaf is a major player in Fremantle and therefore has an obligation to the community to do excellent and attractive development.

While Silverleaf is applying for the Manning development, and soon will be applying for the development of the Woolstores shopping centre and Justice and Police complex in Henderson Street, it still has not completed the development of the Attwell Arcade building and installed all the cladding on the four-storey building.

Completion of the Atwell development should be a requirement by the City of Fremantle before Silverleaf gets approval for any new development in Fremantle.

The planning officers also recommend the requirement of a photographic archival record of the existing building, but that should be amended to a professional high-resolution photographic archival record, as we might otherwise end up with useless low-res amateur photos.

Council meetings will be held at the North Fremantle Community Centre at Thompson Road during the Kings Square Project construction and start at 6 pm.

Roel Loopers

 

 

Comments Off on MANNING BUILDINGS DEVELOPMENT BEFORE PLANNING COMMITTEE

%d bloggers like this: